Start outside the bedroom. Tell your partner which scene or dynamic you love and why, whether that's the banter, the slow burn or the power dynamic. Ask what they'd enjoy, and agree on limits and a stop word. If they're not into full role-play, try one piece of it, such as an outfit, a line or a new setting, as yourselves.
Why book and fanfic fantasies are everywhere
Romance has never been more visible. BookTok keeps romantasy series like Fourth Wing and A Court of Thorns and Roses on bestseller tables, and fan fiction is having a mainstream moment: Bustle and Inverse devoted a whole Fan Fiction Week to it, from the Heated Rivalry fic boom to readers sharing how fanfic shaped what they know about intimacy.
In Bustle's essay “I Owe Everything I Know About Sex To Fan Fiction”, readers describe fanfic giving them words for desire, consent and identity that they hadn't found elsewhere. That's the useful part for couples: a story can help you put a feeling into words.
Being drawn to a scene from a book is a common part of many people's imagination. Enjoying a fantasy doesn't mean you're unhappy with your partner or want your real life to look like the novel. It simply gives you something to talk about.
First, work out what you actually love about the scene
Before you bring anything up, get specific with yourself. Sophia Benoit, Bustle's advice columnist, suggests identifying what is driving the fantasy: the novelty, the characters' power dynamic, or something specific they do or say.
Ask yourself:
- Is it the banter, the teasing back-and-forth before anything happens?
- Is it being pursued, or being the one who pursues?
- Is it the tension: enemies-to-lovers, forbidden, slow burn?
- Is it the setting, like a candlelit castle, a storm or a hotel room?
- Is it a particular line of dialogue you can't stop thinking about?
- Is it the confidence the character has, which you'd like to borrow?
Often the turn-on is one ingredient, not the whole plot. Knowing which one makes the conversation easier and gives you far more ways to try it.
How to bring it up (without making it weird)
Choose a relaxed, non-sexual moment, such as a walk, a lazy breakfast or a drive. Raising a new fantasy mid-moment can feel like pressure, while bringing it up over coffee feels like sharing. Lead with curiosity and make it clear that no is a fine answer.
A few openers:
- “I've been reading this book, and there's a dynamic in it I think would be hot to play with. Can I tell you about it? Zero pressure.”
- “Okay, slightly embarrassing confession: there's a scene in my book I keep thinking about. Want to hear what I like about it?”
- “I'd love to try something a bit new together. Do you have any fantasies you've never mentioned? I'll go first.”
Then really listen. Ask what they enjoy, what they're curious about and what they'd never want to do. It should feel like an exchange, not a pitch.
Ground rules before you try it
Role-play works best when both of you feel safe enough to be playful. Benoit puts it simply: “All sex acts must be consensual and mutually enjoyable.”
- Enthusiastic consent from both of you. Either partner can change their mind at any point, including halfway through.
- Agree on limits beforehand. Talk through what's in, what's out and what's a maybe.
- Pick a stop word. Choose something that would never come up in the scene, so stepping out of character is instant and unambiguous.
- Start small. You can always do more next time.
- Check in afterwards. What felt good? What felt silly? What would you change?
Keep the fantasy between adult fictional characters, and leave out anything you wouldn't want to stand behind outside the bedroom. If a scenario involves real people, power you're uncomfortable with or anything that felt coercive on the page, talk about the feeling you're after rather than recreating the scene.
If you're looking to engage your partner in intriguing conversations, why not try some hypothetical questions for couples? These fun queries will not only keep the conversation lively but also stimulate deep thoughts and potentially reveal insights about each other's personality and thought processes.
Ways to try it, from light to full role-play
You don't have to jump straight into costumes and a script. Think of it as a ladder and stop at whichever rung feels good.
- Share the scene. Read a favorite (non-graphic) passage aloud, or tell your partner what happens and why you love it.
- Borrow one element. An outfit, a nickname, a line of dialogue or a change of setting.
- Play the dynamic as yourselves. Keep your own names and personalities, but lean into the pursuit, the teasing or the tension.
- Try a loose, improvised scene. Agree on a rough premise, but no script, so you can both react naturally.
- Go full role-play. Get into character, with all your ground rules in place.
Benoit suggests mixing and matching, for example dressing as the character but keeping things unscripted, or trying one new thing from the scene “but as yourselves.” For more beginner tips, read our pro tips for newbies at sexual role-play.
What if your partner isn't into it?
That's okay, and it's more common than you'd think. In Bustle's column, a reader whose partner wrote a fanfic-inspired script admitted to feeling “selfish” for not enjoying it. Benoit's answer: “No, you're not being selfish!” Some mismatch in desire is normal, she writes, though over time “there ought to be an even balance of pleasure.”
Her best idea is to look “not for middle ground but other ground.” Rather than a watered-down version of the role-play that neither of you loves, list what turns each of you on and combine those ingredients. Maybe your partner loves spontaneity and you love the character's outfit, so you get the outfit and they get no script. Our tips for avoiding vanilla sex include writing down your fantasies together, which is a good way to find that overlap.
If the answer is a clear no, respect it. Don't push, sulk or bring it up every week. The fantasy is still yours: you can keep enjoying it in your reading and imagination. As Benoit puts it: “You don't need to want all the same things — you just need enough things you're excited to want together.”
If you're the one who's not into it
You never owe anyone a performance. Saying no to a fantasy isn't rejecting your partner, and you can be kind and honest at the same time:
- “I love that you told me this, and I want you to keep telling me things. Acting it out isn't really for me, but I'd love to find a part of it we'd both enjoy.”
- “I felt self-conscious trying it. Could we try just the outfit, or the setting, without the script?”
Offer something you would enjoy, so the conversation stays open rather than ending at no.
When to talk to a professional
If you keep hitting the same mismatch, if one of you feels pressured or ashamed, or if conversations about sex keep ending in hurt, a certified sex therapist or a couples counsellor can help. A good therapist won't judge your reading list. Their job is to help you both talk about desire in a way that feels safe.
FAQ
Is it normal to fantasize about book or fanfic characters?
Yes. Many readers find that a story sparks a fantasy, and it doesn't mean anything is wrong with your relationship. What matters is how you act on it: with honesty, consent and respect for your partner's limits.
How do I tell my partner about a fantasy from a book?
Pick a relaxed, non-sexual moment, explain what you love about the scene (the banter, the tension, the setting) and make it clear there's no pressure. Invite them to share their fantasies too.
What if my partner isn't into role-play?
Look for “other ground” rather than middle ground, as Bustle's Sophia Benoit suggests. Combine what turns each of you on, such as an outfit without a script, or the dynamic played as yourselves. If it's a firm no, respect it.
My partner wants to role-play and I don't. Am I being selfish?
No. Desire mismatches are normal, and you never owe a performance. Be honest and kind, and suggest a piece of the fantasy you'd genuinely enjoy.
How do we set boundaries for role-play?
Before you start, agree on what's in, what's out and what's a maybe. Choose a stop word that would never come up in the scene, start small and check in afterwards. Either of you can stop at any time.
Keep exploring
Search AllWomenStalk for your next read.
Don't Miss the Latest Version
Get the latest stories, save favorites, and share with friends — all in one place.
Create your profile. Earn badges. Level up your reading.
Join Allwomenstalk to track your streaks, collect badges, and earn XP for the things you already do—reading, sharing, and taking quizzes.
- 🔥Daily streaks with gentle boosts for 3, 7, and 30 days.
- 🏅Collect badges like Reader I–III, Socialite, and Quiz Ace.
- ⚡️Earn XP for reads, deep reads, likes, comments, and shares.
It’s free. Takes 30 seconds. Already have an account? Sign in.
Feedback Junction
Where Thoughts and Opinions Converge