What Is Chatfishing? When Your Dating-App Match Lets AI Do the Flirting

Chatfishing is when someone on a dating app uses AI, such as ChatGPT or a “wingman” app, to write or steer their messages, so you end up bonding with polished text they didn’t really write. Unlike catfishing, the person is real. The simplest check is low-drama: suggest a quick phone or video call early.

The bar used to be “looks like their photos.” Now it’s “sounds like their texts.” Here’s what chatfishing is, why it’s spreading, the clues worth noticing, and what to say when you suspect a chatbot is doing the flirting.

What is chatfishing?

Scientific American described chatfishing as a new wave of online deception: instead of using an entirely fake identity, people use artificial intelligence to help them chat up prospective dates.

In practice, that can look like:

  • Pasting a match’s messages, or screenshots of the chat, into a chatbot and asking what to reply.
  • Using wingman apps such as Rizz, Winggg and YourMove AI, which suggest responses to uploaded screenshots. Scientific American notes that YourMove AI’s marketing claims it “puts your texting on cruise control.”
  • Using AI to create or “improve” profile photos.

It’s back in the conversation because Vice reported that it’s “becoming a thing on dating apps,” and that it’s already getting weird.

Chatfishing vs catfishing

CatfishingChatfishing
Is the person real?No, it’s an entirely fake identityYes, the person exists and usually looks like their photos
What’s fake?The whole profile: name, photos, storyThe personality on the page: the wit, warmth and perfect replies
Main riskScams, manipulation and safety threatsGetting attached to someone who isn’t who you thought

AI-edited photos sit somewhere in between. Vice cites a CNN account from Kylee Baxa, whose match had a profile full of photos from Mykonos. He’d never been. When she asked, he admitted he’d used AI to make them because he didn’t have enough good pictures: “Like, they’re still me. It’s still my face,” she recalled him saying. She left shortly afterward.

If you’re worried the person isn’t real at all, that’s a different problem. Read our guide to figuring out if you’re being catfished.

How common is it?

No one can measure chatfishing directly, but surveys suggest AI is already part of a lot of people’s dating lives:

FigureWhat it actually measures
26% of US singles use AI to enhance dating, a 333% jump from the year beforeA survey by Match and researchers at the Kinsey Institute, as reported by Scientific American and the Kinsey Institute. “Enhance dating” covers more than writing messages.
Six in 10 dating-app users believe they’ve seen at least one AI-written conversationA Norton study, as reported by Scientific American. This is what people believe, not confirmed AI use.
Half of respondents thought dating apps had too many chatbots pretending to be peopleA Boston University survey, as reported by Vice
Only 10% of women believed AI-powered dating apps would lead to more successful relationshipsThe same Boston University survey, as reported by Vice

These are separate surveys with different questions and samples, so treat them as signs of a trend rather than numbers to add up.

Why people do it

Mostly, dating apps are exhausting. Vice points out that coming up with something charming to say to a stranger for the seventh time in a week gets old. And the pressure is real: “Dating is in many ways about competition,” Kinsey Institute executive director Justin Garcia told NBC Washington, as quoted by Vice.

The apps themselves are also leaning into AI. According to Scientific American, Hinge uses an AI tool to nudge people toward better prompt answers without writing a script for them, and Facebook Dating has tested a “dating assistant” for brainstorming date ideas. So the line between “a little help” and “a ghostwriter” is getting blurrier.

Signs your match might be using AI

These are clues, not proof. Plenty of people are just good at texting, and plenty of humans write generic messages all on their own. Scientific American notes that people are poor at telling human writing from AI writing, so don’t rely on a gut-feel “detector,” and don’t trust online tools that claim to tell you for sure.

What’s worth noticing:

  • They sparkle in text but fall flat on a call or date. Scientific American says many app users report matches who were “engaging while texting but boring in person.” A big mismatch is a clue.
  • Their replies never quite land on your specifics. Perfectly balanced, polished messages that could be sent to anyone, and that don’t build on the details you shared, can feel off.
  • The tone shifts. Witty paragraphs one day, one-word replies the next, then wit again.
  • Photos look like a stock travel ad. Too-perfect lighting, settings that don’t match each other, or vacations they can’t talk about.

What to do if you think you’re being chatfished

You don’t need to play detective. A few easy moves will tell you most of what you need to know.

  1. Move to voice or video early. Vice suggests starting with a phone call before you spend a month getting attached to someone’s texts. Try: “I’m enjoying this. Want to do a quick call this week?”
  2. Ask something lived-in. Author Brian Christian’s advice for sounding human, as described in Scientific American, is to be “gloriously embodied”: not “I like music,” but the song that made you cry. Ask for the same: “What’s the last thing that made you laugh out loud?” Real stories are hard to fake on the spot.
  3. If the photos look AI-made, just ask. Then decide where your line is. For Kylee Baxa, fake vacation photos were the end of it.
  4. Remember what verification does and doesn’t do. Vice notes that photo verification helps confirm someone’s identity, not that they’re the one writing all those clever replies.
  5. Keep your usual safety habits. Meet in public, tell a friend, and don’t share money or personal details with someone you haven’t met. Our tips to stay safe when online dating cover the basics.

Is it OK to use AI for your own profile?

Using a chatbot to brainstorm a prompt answer or fix a clunky sentence isn’t the same as handing it the whole conversation. Help with a first draft is like asking a friend to read your bio. Outsourcing your personality is where it gets misleading, because the person on the other end is getting to know a machine, not you.

Boston University professor Kathryn Coduto explained the worry to CNN, as reported by Vice: “I do worry for people who have a great interaction, but it ends up being with an AI. And then when they meet the person, it’s not who they thought it was.”

Scientific American’s advice is to let go of saying the right thing and just be real. If you want help being more yourself, try our guide to better conversations on dating apps, and for the other side of AI and romance, read are AI boyfriends making real dating harder?

FAQ

What does chatfishing mean?

Chatfishing is when someone uses AI, such as ChatGPT or a dating “wingman” app, to write or manage their dating-app messages. The person is real, but the charming conversation isn’t really theirs.

What’s the difference between chatfishing and catfishing?

Catfishing uses an entirely fake identity. Chatfishing involves a real person who uses AI to write their messages, and sometimes to create or edit their photos.

How can you tell if someone is using AI to text you on a dating app?

You usually can’t know for sure. Clues include texts that are polished but generic, replies that don’t build on what you said, a tone that keeps shifting, and someone who is much flatter on a call or date than in text. The easiest test is a quick phone or video call.

Is it wrong to use ChatGPT to write dating-app messages?

Brainstorming or polishing a line is a lot like asking a friend for advice. Letting AI run the whole conversation is more misleading, because your match is bonding with text you didn’t write.

What should you do if you think your match is chatfishing?

Suggest a short call early, ask questions that need a real, lived answer, and ask directly about photos that look AI-made. Then decide whether it’s a dealbreaker for you.

Likes, comments and replies are available on the full version.

View full article & comments →